After my last post, I had to take a break from writing. I was too high from my last find and I didn’t know where to go for my next blog post. So, over the last month I’ve decided I’m ready to continue the adventure. Let me start be saying this is a mystery and I need help!
Growing up, I remember my Mother making comments about her mother, Estella Ruben, who we called Momí Stella. Unlike other people who have a hard time getting information for their elder relatives, my mother has never had any problem sharing. She always was willing to share family lore, often unsolicited. My mother was known for telling these enthralling stories—well, at least they were enthralling to me.
One story that comes to mind is one my mother told me when I was young. When my mother was about 5 years old, she went to a local “roots worker” to ask her if she could fix up something to heal her sick mother. My Mother said Momí Stella had been crying and crying, in obvious pain. My mother laughed as she continued, “Mama was a drinker back then, and she would cry when she would get drunk. The roots lady knew my mother wasn’t sick, but had been drinking and she just told me that she would come by later to check on my Mama.”
“Momí Stella used to drink? I had no idea. Man, I would have never known that.” My grandmother lived a pretty wholesome life from my point of view – I never saw her drink.
“Yes, Mama kept us spotless, we had food to eat, she made sure we went to school, and she was a very attentive Mama. But, when she would have bouts of crying spells I thought she was sick. I didn’t know until later that she cried like that when she had been drinking.”
While cooking one day, my mother told me “Momma didn’t know her mother—not even her own mother’s name.” From my mother I learned that Momí Stella’s mother died shortly after she was born. My mother Momma said “my grandmother had other children and after she died, my grandfather, Gabe, sent her other children back to Mowata to live with my grandmother’s family”.
My grandmother died in 1974. According to my Mother, before Momí Stella’s death, she had attempted to try to find her siblings. She wasn’t successful and we, at this point, don’t have any leads to finding this part of my family. My grandmother did not even have a birth certificate. On her death certificate, her mother is listed as unknown.
Once I started being serious about genealogy, I knew this was one of the family mysteries I wanted to solve. Over the years, my mother would repeat this story from time to time. She would also ask if I had found any information yet on Momí’s missing siblings.
Bringing back together this long-ago torn family and enabling my mother to connect with aunts, uncles, their children, their children’s children is one of my greatest prayers. Maybe someone reading this blog post can help me.
So, let me sort out the information I do know about my grandmother’s family. Born July 9th, 1905 in Elton, Louisiana, Estella Ruben, was the daughter of Gabriel “Gabe” Ruben. Gabe, per his death certificate, was born in Ville Platte, Louisiana in 1876. On the 1880 census, I found Gabriel listed as the 4-year son of Lastie and Ellen Ruben. Also listed are Gabriel’s sisters, 8-year Louisa and 2-year Lovenia.
1880 US Census – Lastie Ruben
Lastie, appears to have been the son of John and Jane Rubin. Lastie had a brother named John Ruben files [junior] who married Ernestine Zenon Tomy (Thomas) on February 6, 1869 in Saint Landry Parish, Louisiana. [Opel. Ct. Hse.: Mar. #5224]
As I continued to look at census records, genealogy enthusiasts know that most of the 1890 US census records were by a fire, so the 1900 census are the next set of records available. Unfortunately, I’ve not yet been able to find Gabriel in the 1900 records.
On the 1910 census, I not only picked up the trail of Gabe, it also is the first census on which I find my grandmother [E]stella.
So at the time the census was taken, April 1910, Estella is noted as being 4 years old, which means she would be 5 on her next birthday of July 9th. As, mentioned earlier, Momí Stella did not have a birth certificate so 1905 could be accurate, although her obituary listed her birth year as 1906. The census shows that Gabe and his wife, Eliza, have been married for 5 years and that Eliza had given birth to one child who is alive at the time of the census.
Finding, Gabe, Eliza, and Estella on the 1910 census made me think I had not only found my grandmother, Estella, but I had possibly found her mother, Eliza. That seemed to be the only conclusion. Then, what of the story about the death of my great-grandmother and her children being sent to Mowata? Was that just a myth?
1910 US Census Gabe Ruben
My grandmother had a younger sister named Martha Ruben. On the 1920, Martha, 13, along with my grandmother [E]stella, 14, are both shown with Gabe and Eliza. If Martha is only a year younger than Estella, why isn’t she on the 1910 census in Gabe’s household?
Tragically, Martha dies almost 4 years later of cardiac dropsy, which is edema due to congestive heart failure. At the time of her death, the death certificate says she was 14, giving her a birth year of around 1910. Martha’s mother’s name is illegible on the document and I’ve been unsuccessful in making out the full name. The last name looks to me to be “Antwine”. What do you think is the name?
Marth Ruben’s Death Certificate
So maybe Eliza is the birth mother of Momí Stella, but I don’t think so. At the age of 14, my grandmother would have known the person listed as Liza on the 1920 census. Assuming Liza is the same as the Eliza that is on the 1910 census, it is unlikely my grandmother would have said that she did not know her mother if in fact Liza (and Eliza) was her mother, right?
There’s also a discrepancy with the age of Martha. The 1920 census, it has that she is 13, which means that she was born around 1907. However, her death certificate have that she was 14 when she died in 1924, means that her birth date was about 1910.
On a World War I draft registration dated September 12, 1918 I found Gabe’s significant other as Eliza Harrow.
The trail ends and I still have no information on who could be the mother of Momí Stella. I welcome your ideas on where I should look next to try to solve this mystery.
13 thoughts on “Where Are You, My Grandmother’s People?”
Thanks for sharing. I will make it a point to go get Gabe & Lizzie’s marriage license next week for you. However, you will still seem to have the same question. If Lizzie (Liza) is your grandmother’s mother, why does her death certificate appear to shown another name? Geraldine
Date: Sat, 29 Nov 2014 02:44:56 +0000 To: firstname.lastname@example.org
Okay,Cuz. That would be great, but you are right hat it may not answer the question.
EXCELLENT post Tammy! So glad to see you blogging! Ask Mama Stella what is your next right step. Ask her to guide you to where you should be looking & to see what you need to see. You have good information to work with & the fact this mystery sits in your spirit is a sign. That’s how the Ancestors work. Make sure you’re also using Ancestry’s Message Boards to post what you have & call for what you need. Give it time… the answers are coming!
Thanks Luckie! I have chills all over, so I know you are telling me what I need to do! Thanks for reading it and for the support. The ancestors continue to work me and I have to submit to their calling. Yes, I needed that encouragement.
You know better than most how the Ancestors respond to reference. Take the clues you have & follow each one – line by line. Work what you know. The Ancestors have you!:)
Wow, this is fascinating. I can’t make out the first name on Martha’s death certificate although it looks like it could be Dawn, Jean, Jeun, or something like that. I wonder if maybe your grandmother did know her mother but they had a bad relationship so the story that gets passed on is that she died and the children were sent away? My aunt and grandmother in NC are the family genealogists so the next time I am there I will show them your blog to see if they have any tips or suggestions.
Thanks Erica! I appreciate your comments. I don’t think my grandmother knew her mother, but I guess anything is possible. She stayed close to her father, lived in his household growing up, and even my eldest son, James, lived with her father for a while. Eliza is the only “mother” figure on the census and it is the one name that was known (per my Uncle James) but she was the step-mother. Now, I guess it could be a situation that the father is the one who kept them apart, but spiritually, that’s not the vibe I’m getting. I appreciate any help so let me know what you aunt and grandmother think!
(Thanks also for the name on Martha’s death certificate. Jean and Jeun I had thought about too. Dawn is a new name. I will see if anything come up for that name.
Have you already seen this on family search?
Hi Kristin: Thanks for stopping by! Yes, I saw that tree on familysearch.org – I’m the one that loaded it, lol.
Thanks, though. I’m still open to all ideas are welcomed! Thank you for the support.
I thought you might be lol, but thought I’d check anyway.
Sending email to you.
You’re DNA matched to my husband (MRCA 4.6) ….I believe via DENTON line
Thanks for stopping by. I haven’t posted in a while, but I do plan to post something soon. I will send you an email. Maybe we can correspond and figure out the connection. That would be great if it is on the Denton side as I don’t know any family other than my grandmother. (Of course, this is aside from the Dentons I’ve discovered in my genealogical research. I look forward to connecting with you.